6 Stone Crab Recipes To Cook Up Today

Eating Florida stone crab claws can give you nutrients like other kinds of seafood. They are rich in Omega-3 fatty acids, Vitamin B12, potassium, and selenium.

It's sustainable because they are only harvested for their claws. After that, they go back to the ocean to regenerate.

You can catch stone crabs both in the low and deep waters of the Western North Atlantic. They're usually in season around October to mid-May. Stone crabs can come pre-cooked and chilled.

Although it may look like cooking stone crabs can be difficult, it's quite easy with a recipe. Do you want to try these delicious stone crab recipes and give your palate a treat? Read more to learn these recipes. 

But First, What's So Special About Stone Crab Anyway?

When you think about a seafood delicacy that encapsulates both flavor and sustainability, Florida stone crab claws inevitably come to mind. Stone crab season is a time when seafood enthusiasts eagerly await the chance to indulge in this American culinary treasure

But what exactly sets stone crab apart, making it a must-try for any seafood lover?

Unique Dining Experience

Stone crab claws are not your everyday seafood. Their meat is renowned for a taste that is both sweet and succulent, making them a unique and sought-after delicacy. Whether you're a seasoned seafood aficionado or new to the world of crabs, the flavor profile of stone crab claws is sure to captivate your palate.

Culinary Versatility

Another aspect that sets stone crab apart is its versatility in recipes. They can be the star of a dish or a complementing ingredient. Whether it's the classic stone crab with mustard sauce, a refreshing stone crab salad, or a hearty bisque, stone crab claws adapt beautifully to various culinary styles.

An Icon of American Seafood Cuisine

Originating from the waters around Miami and the Western North Atlantic, stone crab claws are a proud representation of American seafood cuisine. They embody the local flavors and culinary traditions of the region, making them a must-try for anyone looking to explore authentic American dishes.

A Sustainable Choice for Conscious Consumers

In an era where sustainability is key, stone crab claws stand out. Their harvesting method, which allows the crab to regenerate its claw and return to the ocean, is a prime example of sustainable seafood practice. This not only ensures the longevity of the species but also provides consumers with a responsible choice.

What Are Some Stone Crab Recipes To Try?

As we delve deeper into the culinary world of stone crabs, it's clear why they're cherished by seafood lovers. These recipes showcase the versatility and distinct flavors of Florida stone crab claws, transforming them into dishes that are both delectable and easy to prepare. 

Whether you're hosting a special dinner or looking for a new seafood adventure, these recipes will guide you in creating unforgettable stone crab meals.

1. Stone Crab With Mustard Sauce

Stone crabs are most popular with mustard sauce. This recipe is easy and suitable for beginners. The ingredients you’ll need for the sauce are: 

  • Mayonnaise 
  • Lemon Juice 
  • Dijon Mustard 
  • Worcestershire Sauce 
  • Hot Sauce

To do this recipe, all you need is to mix all these ingredients, and you can now enjoy your stone crabs. You don’t need to cook your stone crabs because they are already cooked

If you have raw stone crabs, cooking them is easy, too. You can choose to steam, bake, or grill them. 

2. Stone Crab Bisque

These are the ingredients in making a delicious stone crab bisque. For the Bisque, here's what you need: 

  • 5 cups of stone crab stock 
  • 4 tbsp. Of butter 
  • 1 large diced onion 
  • 4 stalks of diced celery 
  • 2 diced carrots 
  • ½ cup of flour 
  • 2 tbsp of tomato paste 
  • Salt (to taste) 
  • 1 cup of heavy cream 
  • A pinch of cayenne (to taste) 
  • Lemon juice (to taste) 
  • 1-2 cups of stone crab meat 
  • 2 tbsp of parsley minced

You can use other stock like seafood or shellfish juice. Otherwise, here are the ingredients for your stone crab stock: 

  • 1 tbsp. of olive oil 
  • 4 cups of stone crab shells 
  • 1 cup of sherry 
  • 6 cups of water from your boiled stone crab shells

Cook your stock by heating your oil over medium-high. Saute your stone crab shells for a few minutes. Add your sherry and simmer for about 10 minutes. 

Then, add water from the boiled stone crab shells. You can choose to add seafood or clam juice as an alternative. For 30-45 minutes, let it simmer. You may stop once the stock is about five cups. 

Now, for the bisque, heat your butter over medium heat. Add the onions, celery, and carrots, then saute. Reduce the heat and cook for about five minutes or until soft. Once soft, season it with salt and cayenne. Add the flour and stir until it is incorporated. 

Add your stock and let it boil, then let it simmer. Add the tomato paste and let it simmer again for 10 minutes. Slowly mix the heavy cream and let it simmer for 20 minutes until it thickens. After that, strain your bisque and serve it with stone crab meat. 

3. Lobster and Stone Crab Enchilada

If you are looking for a spicy dish, try lobster and stone crab enchilada. To cook an enchilada, here are the ingredients: 

  • 2 uncooked lobster tails cut in half-lengthwise cut into thirds with shells intact 
  • 1 tbsp of fresh lime juice 
  • ¼ cup of olive oil 
  • ⅓ cup of chopped onions 
  • 2 tbsp of chopped green bell pepper 
  • 2 cloves of garlic chopped 
  • 2 tbsp of chopped parsley 
  • ¼ tsp of paprika 
  • 2 large seeded and diced tomatoes 
  • ½ cup of tomato puree 
  • ¾ bottle of clam juice 
  • ½ cup of dry Sherry wine 
  • 1 bay leaf 
  • ¼ tsp of cayenne pepper 
  • 1 lb of cracked stone crab claws

After thawing the lobster, put it in a bowl with fresh lime juice. Toss and let it rest for 16 minutes with occasional tossing to coat the lobster. 

In a large pot, heat your olive oil over high heat. Add the lobster pieces and saute for four minutes until it turns orange. 

After that, return the lobster to the bowl. Reduce the heat to medium and add the chopped bell pepper and onions. Saute until soft, then add the chopped garlic, parsley, and paprika. 

Next, add the diced tomato and tomato puree. For about eight minutes, stir the mixture until it thickens. Add the remaining ingredients and season it with salt and cayenne. Bring to a boil, then add the stone crab claws and lobster with its juices. 

Reduce to medium-low and let it simmer for about 10 minutes until the lobster is tender and cooked. Enjoy this with rice! 

4. Stone Crab With Orange Horseradish Sauce

Stone crab with orange horseradish sauce is another easy recipe that you can try. You will only need these simple ingredients: 

  • ½ cup of mayonnaise 
  • 2 tbsp of thawed orange juice concentrate 
  • 2 tbsp of horseradish 
  • 1 tbsp of coarse-grained Dijon mustard 
  • ⅛ tsp of salt 
  • 2 lb of medium stone crab

Mix all these ingredients and enjoy it with your chilled stone crab claws. You can eat this stone crab recipe with wine

5. Stone Crab Claw With Melted Butter

If you want another easy stone crab recipe that tastes good, try doing this recipe. Here are the ingredients for the stone crab claw with melted butter: 

  • ¼ tbsp of butter 
  • 32 large stone crab claws served chilled 
  • 1 lemon cut into wedges

Steam stone crab claw in a steamer over high heat for about five minutes. Melt butter in a pan, then put it in a serving bowl. Crack the stone crab claws and enjoy with butter and lemon wedges. 

6. Stone Crab Salad

Stone crab salad is a good appetizer. It's also fast and easy to do! Here are the simple ingredients you need: 

  • 1 ½ lb of stone crab meat 
  • 4 oz of chopped onions 
  • 4 oz of chopped celery 
  • Chopped cilantro leaves 
  • Mayonnaise 
  • Crackers (Optional)

In a bowl, mix all the ingredients. Use the right amount of mayonnaise, enough to bind everything together. Put in the chiller for 30 minutes and serve with crackers. 

Expert Tips for Preparing and Enjoying Stone Crab

Now that you've got a taste of some fantastic stone crab recipes, let's equip you with some expert tips to elevate your stone crab cooking and dining experience. These insights will ensure that each crab dish you prepare is delicious and showcases the best of what these magnificent seafood treasures offer.

Choosing the Best Crab

When selecting stone crab claws, look for ones that feel heavy for their size — a sign they're packed with meat. Fresh stone crabs should have a mild, ocean-like scent. 

If you're not near the coast, frozen stone crab claws can be a great alternative. Remember, the key to great seafood starts with quality ingredients.

Proper Thawing Techniques

If you're working with frozen stone crab claws, thaw them in the refrigerator overnight or in cold water for a quick solution. This ensures that the meat retains its texture and flavor.

Cooking to Perfection

For raw stone crabs, boiling is a preferred method. Bring your pot of boiling water to a gentle simmer before adding the claws. This method cooks the crab evenly, preserving its delicate texture. Typically, large stone crab claws need about eight to 10 minutes of cooking.

Grilling for Extra Flavor

If you prefer a smoky touch, grilling stone crab claws can add an incredible depth of flavor. Lightly brush the claws with olive oil and place them on a hot grill for a few minutes on each side. Serve with a squeeze of fresh lemon to enhance the grilled taste.

Steaming for Tenderness

Steaming is another excellent method, especially if you want to retain the crab's natural moisture and flavor. Simply steam the claws in a pot of boiling water for a few minutes. This method is gentle and perfect for preserving the delicate texture of the crab meat.

Baking for Convenience

For a hands-off approach, baking stone crab claws in the oven is ideal. It's as simple as placing them on a baking sheet, seasoning lightly, and letting the oven do the work. This method is great for busy nights when you want a delicious meal without much fuss.

The Art of Cracking Crab Claws

There’s an art to cracking stone crab claws. Use a seafood cracker or the back of a heavy spoon. Gently crack each section of the claw and knuckle, being careful not to shatter the shell into small pieces. This way, you can extract the meat in larger, more appealing chunks.

Serving Suggestions

Stone crab claws are traditionally served cold, making them a refreshing and easy appetizer. Accompany them with dipping sauce options like the classic mustard dipping sauce, a tangy horseradish sauce, or melted butter with a squeeze of fresh lemon for added zest.

Pairing With Sides

Complement your stone crab dishes with sides that enhance their natural flavors. A light salad, steamed green beans, or even crab cakes can be great additions. For a heartier meal, consider pairing it with warm sides like roasted vegetables or creamy pasta.

Exploring Beyond Claws

While stone crab claws are the star, don't overlook other seafood options. Blue crabs, for instance, offer a different but equally delightful taste experience. Experimenting with various types of crab can add diversity to your seafood repertoire.

The Bottom Line

At George Stone Crab, our goal is to bring a taste of the ocean right to your table, with the added assurance of sustainable practices and unmatched quality. Whether you're experimenting with new culinary adventures or are a seasoned seafood lover, these versatile stone crab recipes offer a mouth-watering experience. 

From the classic mustard sauce pairing to a spicy enchilada treat, stone crabs allow you to create delectable dishes that speak to varied palates. Alongside the rich, succulent flavor, their cultivation practices promote sustainability, making them a responsible choice for seafood connoisseurs. 

So, let your curiosity lead the way and dive into the enticing flavors of stone crab today!


Research: Consumers’ Sustainability Demands Are Rising | HBR

Eat this Word: Stone Crabs | James Beard Foundation

Stone Crab | FDACS

Sign up now for discounts!